It's been a subject of much discussion for me that I believe Mr. Depp is a lovely human and a good actor, however, I LOVE Jack Sparrow, no doubt about it.
So we're in accordance.

I get to choose what I want to believe...sorta like a buffet I suppose
A good approach, IMO. Far more honest than the oh-so-popular "I'm innocent, I only do what my religion orders me". I always grind my teeth hearing this 'argument'. Man, I want reply then, whatever your religion orders or forbids you, you have chosen this religion in the first place.
(Huh, posting what I considered an interesting observation in the form of satire, I'd never thought it'll lead to such grave discussions. :)